| Quarterbacks: | Different Scoring System | Different Scoring System | Different Scoring System | Different Scoring System | Different Scoring System | |
| Rank | Actual (Yahoo default) | ESPN (Consensus of users) | Sportsline (expert) | Yahoo (Projections*) | NFL Record & Fact Book (Projections) | KUBIAK (Projections) |
| 1 | Carson Palmer | Peyton Manning | Peyton Manning | Peyton Manning | Peyton Manning | Peyton Manning |
| 2 | Peyton Manning | Daunte Culpepper | Daunte Culpepper | Daunte Culpepper | Daunte Culpepper | Daunte Culpepper |
| 3 | Tom Brady | Donovan McNabb | Donovan McNabb | Donovan McNabb | Donovan McNabb | Donovan McNabb |
| 4 | Matt Hasselbeck | Trent Green | Brett Favre | Trent Green | Trent Green | Matt Hasselbeck |
| 5 | Eli Manning | Marc Bulger | Trent Green | Brett Favre | Kerry Collins | Kerry Collins |
| 6 | Drew Brees | Brett Favre | Kerry Collins | Tom Brady | Michael Vick | Marc Bulger |
| 7 | Jake Delhomme | Michael Vick | Tom Brady | Marc Bulger | Marc Bulger | Byron Leftwich |
| 8 | Drew Bledsoe | Kerry Collins | Marc Bulger | Michael Vick | Matt Hasselbeck | Jake Plummer |
| 9 | Jake Plummer | Tom Brady | Michael Vick | Drew Brees | Aaron Brooks | Tom Brady |
| 10 | Mark Brunell | Aaron Brooks | Matt Hasselbeck | Matt Hasselbeck | Carson Palmer | Aaron Brooks |
| 11 | Kerry Collins | Matt Hasselbeck | Jake Plummer | Kerry Collins | Brett Favre | David Carr |
| 12 | Michael Vick | Drew Brees | Jake Delhomme | Carson Palmer | Tom Brady | Chad Pennington |
| 13 | Trent Green | Jake Plummer | Carson Palmer | Aaron Brooks | Jake Plummer | Carson Palmer |
| 14 | Ben Roethlisberger | Jake Delhomme | Drew Brees | Jake Delhomme | David Carr | Ben Roethlisberger |
| 15 | Steve McNair | Carson Palmer | Steve McNair | Ben Roethlisberger | Jake Delhomme | Brett Favre |
| 16 | Gus Frerotte | David Carr | Aaron Brooks | Jake Plummer | Chad Pennington | Trent Green |
| 17 | Donovan McNabb | Byron Leftwich | Chad Pennington | Drew Bledsoe | Steve McNair | Brian Griese |
| 18 | Byron Leftwich | Ben Roethlisberger | Byron Leftwich | Chad Pennington | Byron Leftwich | Drew Brees |
| 19 | Brett Favre | Chad Pennington | David Carr | Eli Manning | Brian Griese | Jake Delhomme |
| 20 | Aaron Brooks | Brian Griese | Brian Griese | Steve McNair | Joey Harrington | Michael Vick |
| 21 | David Carr | Steve McNair | Joey Harrington | Byron Leftwich | Drew Brees | Eli Manning |
| 22 | Mark Bulger | Joey Harrington | Eli Manning | Joey Harrington | Patrick Ramsey | J.P. Losman |
| 23 | Kurt Warner | Kyle Boller | Kurt Warner | David Carr | Eli Manning | Kyle Boller |
| 24 | Brad Johnson | Drew Bledsoe | Ben Roethlisberger | Kurt Warner | Ben Roethlisberger | Drew Bledsoe |
| 25 | Kyle Boller | Rex Grossman | Drew Bledsoe | Patrick Ramsey | Kurt Warner | Steve McNair |
| 26 | Joey Harrington | Eli Manning | Kyle Boller | Brian Griese | Drew Bledsoe | Kurt Warner |
| 27 | Chris Simms | Kurt Warner | Patrick Ramsey | Rex Grossman | Joey Harrington | |
| 28 | Trent Dilfer | J.P. Losman | J.P. Losman | Trent Dilfer | Trent Dilfer | |
| 29 | Kelly Holcomb | Trent Dilfer | J.P. Losman | Jeff Garcia | ||
| 30 | David Garrard | Tim Rattay | Kyle Boller | Alex Smith | ||
| 31 | Josh McCown | Gus Frerotte | Tim Rattay | Tim Rattay | ||
| 32 | Brooks Bollinger | Kyle Orton | Gus Frerotte | Patrick Ramsey | ||
| 33 | Billy Volek | Billy Volek | A.J. Feeley | |||
| 34 | Brad Johnson | Jeff Garcia | Gus Frerotte | |||
| 35 | Kelly Holcomb | Kelly Holcomb | Chad Hutchinson | |||
| 36 | Alex Smith | A.J. Felley | Kyle Orton | |||
| 37 | Philip Rivers | Jay Fiedler | Billy Volek | |||
| 38 | Jon Kitna | Brad Johnson | Kelly Holcomb | |||
| 39 | Jay Fielder | Jim Sorgi | Josh McCown | |||
| 40 | Tommy Maddox | Mike McMahon | Drew Henson | |||
| 41 | x – Alex Smith | Matt Schaub | ||||
| 42 | Matt Schaub | Philip Rivers | ||||
| 43 | Josh McCown | Jon Kitna | ||||
| 44 | Chad Hutchinson | David Garrard | ||||
| 45 | Drew Henson | Jay Fiedler | ||||
| 46 | David Garrard | Tommy Maddox | ||||
| 47 | Philip Rivers | |||||
| 48 | Jon Kitna | |||||
| 49 | Luke McCown | |||||
| 50 | Tommy Maddox | |||||
| 51 | x – Aaron Rodgers | |||||
| 52 | Kordell Stewrt | |||||
| 53 | x – Jason Campbell | |||||
| 54 | Jeff Blake | |||||
| 55 | Mark Brunell | |||||
| 56 | Tony Banks | |||||
| 57 | Jamie Martin | |||||
| 58 | Todd Collins | |||||
| 59 | Chris Simms | |||||
| 60 | Doug Flutie |
